Key Lime Pie — Red Lobster Desserts Menu 2026

Red Lobster’s Key Lime Pie is a refreshing and creamy dessert made with real Key Lime juice for an authentic, zesty flavour. It rests on a buttery graham cracker crust, creating the perfect balance of tangy citrus and smooth sweetness.

Key Lime Pie is the lightest dessert on the Red Lobster menu at 580 calories a full 530 calories below the Chocolate Wave, and meaningfully lower than every other dessert option here. For anyone trying to end a heavy seafood meal without going fully overboard on dessert, this is the obvious choice.

The tart, citrus forward flavor is also the main thing distinguishing it from everything else on this list every other dessert here is built around chocolate or cheesecake style richness, while Key Lime Pie brings acidity and brightness instead. After a buttery, garlic heavy seafood entrée, that contrast tends to land well; it cuts through the richness of the meal rather than adding to it.

At $8.99, it’s tied with the Chocolate Wave for one of the cheaper desserts on the menu, which combined with the lower calorie count makes it arguably the best value option here if value includes not needing to plan the rest of the day’s eating around dessert alone.